|   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                            OUR JUDGMENTS  | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          GA No. 1 of 2023 In CS No. 124 of 2023  
                              Umang Goenka  
                                VS. 
				A. B. Nirvan Builders Pvt. Ltd. & Others
  
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          CRR No. 878 of 2022, decided on May 3,2024  
                              Premlata Mago & Another  
                                VS. 
				State Of West Bengal
  
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          GA No. 1 of 2023 In CS No. 120 of 2023  
                              Meenakshi Goenka  
                                VS. 
				Canon Properties Private Limited & Ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          C.N.R No - WBSP02-000432-2000  
                              Ambe Plywoods Private Limited  
                                VS. 
				The Indian Oil Corporation Limited
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          APO/158/2020 [WITH WPO/975/2016] IA NO: GA/5/2023  
                              THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ANR.  
                                VS. 
				SMT. MADHUMITA GUPTA AND ORS.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          M.A.T. 2506 of 2023 (CAN 1 of 2023) (CAN 2 of 2024)  
                              Kunal Kumar Adhikary & Anr.  
                                VS. 
				The Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          Civil Appeal No. 6466 of 2024  
                              KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ANR.  
                                VS. 
				BIMAL KUMAR SHAH & ORS.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          C.R.R. 878 of 2022  
                              Premlata Mago and Another  
                                VS. 
				The State Of West Bengal
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          C.R.R. 64 of 2024  
                              Dr. Prakash Kumar Hazra  
                                VS. 
				The State
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          M.A.T. 2068 of 2023   WITH   IA No. CAN 1 of 2023 
                              National Jute Manufactures Corporation Limited & Anr.  
                                VS. 
				Sushil Kumar Thard & Anr.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          CRM (A) 4191 of 2023  
                              In the matter of : Indranil Saha  
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          Title Suit No. 1336/2018  
                              Akhilesh Goenka  
                                VS. 
				Deepa Goenka
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          Title Suit 2126 of 2009  
                              R9586/2014  
				CNR. No. WBSP020002432009
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P.A. 13923 of 2018  
                              Kunal Kumar Adhikary & Anr.  
                                VS. 
				The Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          WPA 4751 of 2023  CAN 1 of 2023 
                              Sushil Kumar Thard  
                                VS. 
				National Jute Manufactures Corporation Limited & Ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P.O. 2289 of 2022 IA NO. GA 2 of 2023  
                              The Kolkata Municipal Corporation And Ors.  
                                VS. 
				State Of West Bengal And Ors. 
                              With W.P.O. 2380 of 2022  Rameshwar Properties Private Limited  
                                VS. 
				State Of West Bengal And Ors. 
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P.A 3574 of 2020 
                              Reliable Facilities Services Private Limited & Anr.  
                                VS. 
				Chittaranjan National Cancer Institute & Ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          C.O. No. 2853 of 2022 
                              Indian Oil Corporation Limited  
                                VS. 
				Ambe Plywoods Private Limted & ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          Title suit no. 1336/2018 
                              CNR: WBSP02-003141-2018  
                                J.O. (wb01066)
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          M.A.T. 2043 & 2048 of 2022 
                              Dilip Chandra Chatterjee & ORS.  
                                VS. 
                                Kolkata Municipal Corporation & ORS.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          APC 02 of 2022 
                              Sova Sen & ORS.  
                                VS. 
                                Competent Authority, Kolkata
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          M.A.
                              No.2107/2022 in CA No. 2402/2015 
                              Nemai Chandra Kumar (D) THR. LRS. & ORS.  
                                VS. 
                                Mani Square Ltd.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          M.A.
                              No.07/2021/EZ 
                              1. Abhinandan Chopra, 2.
                                Gaurav Chopra,  
                                VS. 
                                1. Union Of India, 2. State of West Bengal, 3.
                                West Bengal Pollution Board, 4. M/s. Rail Udyog
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P.A 3574 of
                              2020 
                              Reliable Facilities Services
                                Private Limited & Anr.  
                                VS. 
                                Chittaranjan National Cancer Institute &
                                Ors.  | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          APD No. 101 of
                              2017 
                            With 
                            CS No. 145 of 2006 
                              vijay shree pvt. ltd.  
                                VS. 
                                union of india & ORS.  | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          Miscellaneous
                              application no. 609/2021
                               
                             Hooghly Mills Company
                              Ltd.  
                              v/s 
                              The State of West Bengal & ANR. | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          
                             
                           | 
                        
                        
                          APO No. 181 of
                              2016 
                              GA No. 1872 of 2016 
                            With 
                            WP No. 327 of 2016 
                              RAMESHWAR PROPERTIES
                                  PRIVATE LTD.  
                                  VS. 
                                  STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.
                                
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          A.P.O. 523 of
                              2017 
                            W.P. No. 930 of 2016 
                            KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
                              & ANR. 
                              VS. 
                              BIMAL KUMAR SHAH 
                             
                              A.P.O. 210 of 2018 
                              W.P. No. 930 of 2016 
                            BIMAL KUMAR SHAH 
                              Vs. 
                              STATE OF WEST BENGAL & Ors. | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          A.P.O. NO. 3 OF
                              2017 
                            With 
                            C.S. NO. 369 OF 2014 
                            Merlin Projects Limited 
                              v/s 
                              Pawan Kumar Agarwal 
                            With 
                            A.P.D. NO. 6 OF 2017 
                            With 
                            C.S. NO. 369 OF 2014 
                            Merlin Projects Limited 
                              v/s 
                              Pawan Kumar Aagarwal | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P. 11583(W) of
                              2019  
                             Suparna Mitra  
                              v/s 
                              The State of West Bengal & Ors. | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          
                            WP 45 OF 2018 
                              GA 1328 OF 2019 
                              with 
                              GA 1381 of 2019 
                              WP 388 of 2018
                            
                            Shiromani Flat Owners'
                                Association & Ors.  
                            v/s 
                            Kolkata Municipal
                                Corporation & Ors. 
                                With 
                                Mayavati Trading Private Limited 
                                v/s 
                                Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Ors.
                               
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          W.P. No. 115 (W)
                              of 2019  
                             In re : Vijai Shree
                              Pvt. Limited  
                              v/s 
                              Howrah Municipal Corporation & Ors.  | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          GA No. 3068 of
                              2018 
                              WP No. 533 0f 2017  
                            
                            Vijai Shree Private Limited
                               
                            v/s 
                            Board of Trustees of the
                                Port of Kolkata & Ors.
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P. 266 (W) of
                              2019 
                            
                            Ajoy Das  
                            v/s 
                            State of W.B. & Ors.
                             
                             | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                               
                              
                           | 
                        
                        
                          
                            GA. No 3675 of 2015 
                              CS No 369 of 2014 
                              GA No 1118 of 2015
                            Merlin Projects Limited 
                            v/s 
                            Smt. Giniya Devi Agaewala
                                & ANR. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P. No. 15609 (W)
                              of 2018 
                            Emami Agrotech Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Union of Indian & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          W.P.
                              No. 13044 (W) of 2018 
                            Birendra Nath Dey  
                            v/s 
                              District Magistrate, Murshidabad & Ors. | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          MAT
                              518 of 2018  
                              with  
                              CAN 3469 of 2018 
                            Nadia District Central Co-
                                operative Bank Limited & Anr. 
                            v/s 
                            Ramprasad Dasgupta &
                                Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          CRM
                              5789 of 2018 
                            Sanjay Pandey and another  
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          CRM
                              No 6437 of 2018 
                            In Re - An Application for
                                anticipatory bail under section 438 of the code
                                of criminal procedure filed on 20.08.2018 in
                                connection with New Town Police Station Case No
                                271 of 2018 dated 02.07.2018 for alleged offence
                                punishable under Sections 418/420/406/120B of
                                the Indian Penal Code.  
                            and 
                            In Re   Rejeev Talwar &
                                ANR. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          AP.
                              No 953 of 2017 
                              GA No 3641 of 2017 
                              GA No 3385 of 2017 
                            Bajaj Allianz General
                                Insurance Company Pvt. Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Vijai Shree Pvt. Ltd. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          WP 17328 (W) of
                              2018 
                            Ramprasad Dasgupta &
                                Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal
                                & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. 17460 (W) of 2018
                            Emami Agrotech Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Union of Indian & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            Civil Appeal Nos. 2548 of 2006
                            State of West Bengal and
                                others [Appellant(s)] 
                            v/s 
                            Calcutta Mineral Supply Co.
                                Pvt. Ltd. and another [Respondent(s)] Judgement
                                : M.Y.Eqbal, J. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            Civil Appeal No. 6402 of 2017
                            Manbasa Devi 
                            v/s 
                            Calcutta Landing and
                                Shipping Company Limited and Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            CO 1285 of 2017
                            Calcutta Landing and
                                Shipping Company Limited 
                            v/s 
                            Manbasa Devi and others 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            WP 791 of 2016
                            Arijit Paul & ANR. 
                            v/s 
                            The Kolkata Municipal
                                Corporation & ORS. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. 9543 (W) of 2016
                            Howrah Mills Company
                                Limited 
                            v/s 
                            The Employees State
                                Insurance Corporation & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            GA No.1230 OF 2016
                            WELL WISHER ELECTRONICS
                                PVT. LTD & ANR. 
                            v/s 
                            STATE OF WEST BENGAL &
                                ORS. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            WP NO.235 OF 2016
                            RAMESHWAR PROPERTIES PVT.
                                LTD. 
                            v/s 
                            KMC & ORS. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. 26998(W) of 2015
                            Howrah Mills Co. Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            The Union of India &
                                Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            GA No.3675 of 2015
                            Merlin Projects Limited 
                            v/s 
                            Smt. Giniya Devi Agarwala
                                & ANR. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            RVW No. 240 of 2015
                            Smt. Jaya Sarkar 
                            v/s 
                            Smt. Tanushree Sarkar 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. No. 26998 (W) of 2015
                            Howrah Mills Co. Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            The Union of India &
                                Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             Sanatan Merchants Pvt. Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Narpat Bokadia 
                            Before : 
                              The Hon'ble Justice I.P.Mukerji 
                              Date : 14th July, 2014
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C.O. 1720 of 2013
                            Re : Praneet Kumar Bajpaie
                                .. Petitioner. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          DABUR
                              INDIA LTD. & ANR  
                              v/s
                            STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            In the matter of :
                            M/s. Vijai Shree Ltd.,
                                Shibpur, Howrah (Petitioner) 
                            v/s 
                            The State (Opposite Party) 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | Landmark Judgement on
                            THIKA TENANCY. | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            Case No. Misc. Appeal 379/2013
                            DTL Abasan Pvt. Ltd. &
                                30 Others ... 
                            v/s 
                            The General Manager adn the
                                Divisional Railway Manager, Sealdah Division,
                                Eastern Railway .... 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C.A. No. 9005 of 2012
                            Mitul Chatterjee (Barman) 
                            v/s 
                            Rajesh Burman 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             Greenvally Towers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. 
                            v/s 
                            State of West bengal & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            WP 9590(w) of 2009
                            Mahendra Kumar Narhany
                                & Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal
                                & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            CRR No. 1596 / 2014
                            Dr. Prakash Kumar Hazra 
                            v/s 
                            State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C.S. No. 65 of 2003
                            Rajat Bose 
                            v/s 
                            Shoma Patronobis 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. No. 52 of 2008
                            Om Prakash Prasad 
                            v/s 
                            Official Trustee of West
                                Bengal & ORS 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.
                              25797 Of 2004
                            Sukumar De
                                .................. Petitioner(S) 
                            v/s 
                            Bimala Auddy & Ors
                                .............. Respondent(S) 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. No.781 of 2012
                            Tapan Bhattacharya &
                                Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            The Kolkata Municipal
                                Corporation & Ors. 
                            W.P. No.842 of 2012
                            Carmel Jyoti Nilaya 
                            v/s 
                            State of West Bengal &
                                Ors. 
                            W.P. No.865 of 2012
                            Tapan Bhattacharya &
                                Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            The Kolkata Municipal
                                Corporation & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W.P. No.980 of 2011
                            Emami Biotech Ltd. &
                                Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            State Of West Bengal &
                                Ors. Division Bench 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            GA No. 229 of 2013 
                              W.P. No. 980 of 2011
                            Emami Biotech Ltd. &
                                ANR. 
                            v/s 
                            State of West Bengal &
                                ORS. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            A.P.O. No 194 of 2012 
                              C.P. No. 28 of 1993 
                              C.A. No. 145 of 2011
                            Gloster Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Fort Gloster Industries
                                Ltd. & ANR. 
                            & 
                            A.P.O. No 287 of 2012 
                              C.P. No. 28 of 1993 
                              C.A. No. 145 of 2011
                            Bowreah Jute Mills (P) Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Gloster Ltd. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            CC No. 13492 of 2012
                            M/S. Agribiotech Industries
                                LTD. & ANR 
                            v/s 
                            The State of Rajasthan
                                & ORS. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            S. B. Civil Writ Petition No.
                              10696 of 2012
                            M/S. Agribiotech Industries
                                Limited 
                            v/s 
                            The State of Rajasthan 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 3762 of 2012
                            Prashant Goenka 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 3761 of 2012
                            Radheshyam Goenka 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 1099 of 2012
                            Radheshyam Agarwal 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 4694 of 2012
                            Ravi Todi 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 5662 of 2012
                            Shrawan Kumar Todi 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 4693 of 2012
                            Manish Goenka 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. M. No 6459 of 2012
                            Priti Sureka 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. S. No. 41 OF 2010
                            Gloster Jute Mills Limited 
                            v/s 
                            Hooghly Mills Company
                                Limited & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            WP 403 OF 2010
                            Bidyut Addya & Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            Sri Sukumar Dey & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            A. P. No. 211 OF 2010
                            Gloster Jute Mills Limited 
                            v/s 
                            Hooghly Mills Company
                                Limited 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W. P. No. 18735 (W) of 2006
                            Howrah Mills Company
                                Limited & Anr. 
                            v/s 
                            Howrah Municipal
                                Corporation & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. A. No. 2639 of 2006
                            Howrah Mills Company
                                Limited & Anr. 
                            v/s 
                            Md. Shamin & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            R .V. W. No. 4157 of 2005 with CAN
                              No. 9936 of 2005
                            Puranmall Goenka 
                            v/s 
                            Mrs. Savitri Devi Daga 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W. P. No. 1919 of 2005
                            Keventer Projects Ltd. and
                                Another 
                            v/s 
                            The Union of India and
                                Others 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W. P. No. 19224 (W) of 2004
                            Tutul Ice Plant Private
                                Limited & Anr. 
                            v/s 
                            Howrah Municipal
                                Corporation & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            F. A. T. No. 1666 of 2003
                            Mrs. Savitri Devi Daga 
                            v/s 
                            Shri Puranmall Goenka 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W. P. No. 17060 (W) of 2003
                            Howrah Mills Company
                                Limited 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal
                                & Anr. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            W. P. L. R. T. No. 382 OF 2001
                            Grantio Ceramics Lts. 
                            v/s 
                            Janardhan Senapati &
                                Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. R. No. 13 of 2000 with C. R.
                              A. N. No. 627 of 2000
                            Mrs. Rekha Dixit 
                            v/s 
                            State of West Bengal &
                                Anr. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          
                            C. R. R. No. 12 of 2000
                            Jay Prakash Gaur 
                            v/s 
                            The State of West Bengal
                                & Anr. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             Edward Keventer (P) Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Bihar State Agricultural Marketing Board 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             State of West Bengal 
                            v/s 
                            Terra Firma Investment & Trading (P)
                                Ltd. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             Silverline Forum (P) Ltd. 
                            v/s 
                            Rajiv Trust 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             Gloster Jute Mills Limited 
                            v/s 
                            Hooghly Mills Company Limited 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   | 
                        
                        
                          | 
                             Tapan Bhattacharya & Ors. 
                            v/s 
                            Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Ors. 
                           | 
                            | 
                        
                        
                          |   |